Home › Indiana › Greenwood › The NY Slice
The NY Slice
4.6 ★★★★★ 813 Google reviews · Mobile pizza oven catering — Greenwood, Indiana
By appointment — contact to check your date
New York-style pizzeria at Greenwood Park Mall serving thin-crust and specialty pies, plus calzones.
Plan your event
- Serves the Greenwood, IN area — confirm your venue is inside their travel range when you inquire
- Wood-fired oven a real wood fire cooking on site — check that your venue allows open-flame cooking and has space for the oven or trailer to park
- Phone +1 317-887-1009
- Website thenyslice.com
Booking basics
Pizza caterers book by the date, not the walk-in — popular Saturdays (especially May–October) go months out, so inquire early with your date, venue, guest count, and whether you want full catering or an oven drop-off. Most will hold a date with a deposit and a signed agreement.
Menu add-ons they offer
“We Ordered Da Big Greek, Da Meat Yorker, garlic knots and Da Big Greek salad with the Greek dressing!”
“Pizza is always amazing, and the cannolis are the perfect treat to wash it all down.”
What hosts say again and again
“The crust is perfectly thin and crispy, the cheese is super flavorful, and the toppings were so fresh.”
“The owner is really nice and friendly, and he made me feel very welcome even when I ordered close to closing time.”
“We Ordered Da Big Greek, Da Meat Yorker, garlic knots and Da Big Greek salad with the Greek dressing!”
From the reviews
My husband and I went in just for two slices only. When I tell you we went into the car took a couple of bites of this pizza never left the parking lot. Went back inside and order the biggest pizza they had because that’s how good it was.
I could not wait to write this review. Coming from Louisville, this pizza place is absolutely incredible. But the highlight of our visit was talking to Dan, the owner. He operates this location BY HIMSELF. He was soo friendly and excited to talk about this pizza.
I love the pizza and cannolis and garlic knots from this place! Closest thing to the pizza I get on the east coast. Not to mention, this person running this place is also very friendly and outgoing and welcoming to new customers and reoccurring ones as well :) definitely will come again if I am in town.
This is Authentic Real NY pizza!!! If you have ever wanted to try NYC pizza, we have it in Greenwood Indiana. No need to travel to the city just come here. This isn't some mall Pizza. Dan is absolutely the best!! It's family when you come here!
Pizza caterers near The NY Slice
Brozinni Pizzeria
4.6 ★★★★★ 1,937 reviews
Family-friendly pizza place features the Big Apple's signature crust & a small menu of Italian eats.
Brozinni Pizzeria at Speedway
4.6 ★★★★★ 966 reviews
Familiar and inviting pizzeria featuring a menu of New York-style classics, wings and calzones.
Indy Fresh Catering
4.8 ★★★★★ 105 reviews
Familiar Italian dishes, pizzas and taco bars served buffet-style or via delivery.