Home › Illinois › Crystal Lake › Nancy's Pizza Crystal Lake

Nancy's Pizza Crystal Lake

4.5 ★★★★★ 287 Google reviews · Mobile pizza oven catering — Crystal Lake, Illinois

By appointment — contact to check your date

Nancy's Pizza Crystal Lake, mobile pizza oven catering in Crystal Lake, IL — photo 1
Nancy's Pizza Crystal Lake, mobile pizza oven catering in Crystal Lake, IL — photo 2
Nancy's Pizza Crystal Lake, mobile pizza oven catering in Crystal Lake, IL — photo 3
Nancy's Pizza Crystal Lake, mobile pizza oven catering in Crystal Lake, IL — photo 4
Nancy's Pizza Crystal Lake, mobile pizza oven catering in Crystal Lake, IL — photo 5

Chicago-style stuffed pizza is the draw at this restaurant also offering thin-crust pies & pastas.

Plan your event

Booking basics

Pizza caterers book by the date, not the walk-in — popular Saturdays (especially May–October) go months out, so inquire early with your date, venue, guest count, and whether you want full catering or an oven drop-off. Most will hold a date with a deposit and a signed agreement.

A directory can't see anyone's calendar — availability, travel fees, and minimums always come from the caterer directly.

Menu add-ons they offer

Extras hosts mention in reviews of Nancy's Pizza Crystal Lake or that the caterer describes itself — the fastest way to tell whether they can cover the whole food side of your event.

🥗 Salads & Appetizers

Who else offers salads & appetizers →

Add-on mentions are mined from reviews and the caterer's own materials — menus change season to season, so confirm what's included when you get your quote.

What hosts say again and again

The things reviewers bring up again and again across 287 Google reviews — with their own words as proof.

⭐ the pizza wows guests 6 mentions

“We believe it is some of the best Pizza around the LITH/Algonquin/Huntley/Crystal Lake area.”

🕐 professional & punctual 5 mentions

“The pizza arrives nice and warm, orders are accurate, delivery people very nice and professional.”

😊 friendly & fun 3 mentions

“The staff are friendly and helpful, and the thin AND deep dish are great.”

From the reviews

Decided to try a different pizza place in the area. Just got a XL thin crust pepperoni. It arrived very timely and hot. The delivery guy was super nice. The pizza tasted great. Definitely gonna order from here again

★★★★★ — Duram via Google, Dec 2021

The staff at this location takes quality very seriously work very hard! My favorite pizzas are the super thin and rustic! They will make nearly anything you want.

★★★★★ — Rebecca via Google, Dec 2025

Pizza from Nancy's is always make correctly and is very satisfying. We believe it is some of the best Pizza around the LITH/Algonquin/Huntley/Crystal Lake area.

★★★★★ — Mark via Google, May 2026

Delicious pizza! I've only had deliveries at this time. The pizza arrives nice and warm, orders are accurate, delivery people very nice and professional.

★★★★★ — Niki via Google, May 2026

Excerpts from public Google reviews. Read all 287 reviews →

Where Nancy's Pizza Crystal Lake is based

1295 N Randall Rd, Crystal Lake, IL60014

View on Google Maps Instagram · Facebook

Pizza caterers near Nancy's Pizza Crystal Lake

Bee's Pizza

5 ★★★★★ 15 reviews

1095 Pingree Rd, Crystal Lake, IL

the pizza wows guests

2.1 miles away

Your Sister's Tomato

4.6 ★★★★★ 189 reviews

110 Irving Ave, Woodstock, IL

Wood-fired the pizza wows guestsprofessional & punctualfriendly & fun

Relaxed eatery for wood-fired pies and pizza, as well as salads and sandwiches.

9.2 miles away

Tievoli Pizza Bar

4.7 ★★★★★ 430 reviews

44 W Palatine Rd, Palatine, IL

Corporate events Wood-fired the pizza wows guestsfriendly & funcrowd-pleasing menu options

Pizzas and Italian-style comfort food served in a relaxed setting.

16.2 miles away

All mobile pizza caterers in Crystal Lake, IL →

Listing verified July 2026 from public business records and hosts’ reviews. Something out of date? Report a correction. Run this service? Claim your listing — it's free.